Awhile back I did a poll on WSAD against the Arrow Keys, I quite enjoyed it, so I decided to make a new one, seeing which is better: Ranged or Melee. I don't know where to place Privateer, for it does get some magic attacks, like the bombs and such. But it doesn't deal Magical damage, so I think I'll clarify it with Melee. Okay, enough explaining, details do bore me. I'd choose ranged, no pesky Overwatch and Repel boarders!
1. Swashbuckler, Privateer, Buccaneer. 2. Musketeer and Witchdoctor
P.S. Yes, I am being bias to my own class, don't tell anyone.. shhh.
Well I like the critical moves of melee classes... then again I like all the critical moves. They're all pretty awesome to watch. I love all the classes, but if I really had to choose on which I prefer in combat would probably be ranged. With my musketeer, I do always tend to have a team of musketeer companions so I could grant them Overwatch or Bust Fire for 3 rounds... They're quite trigger happy. With all the overwatch and bombs in the way, it's quite difficult for enemies to approach us without getting 1/2 to 2/3 of their health gone. Also, since they're not as many ranged enemies compared to melee enemies we don't trigger their First Strike, Repel Boarders (I let them come to me), Riposte, and Vengeance Strike.