who is better!

AuthorMessage
Petty Officer
Sep 02, 2011
67
here are a few i know the answers to

Mike vs Milo

subodai vs kobe

Monkey crossbowman vs monkey explorer

sarah vs barnabus

scratch vs ratbeard

and finally

gortez vs troggy chief

you decide! I know the answers but do you?

Bosun
Oct 15, 2012
362
unicornman987 on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
here are a few i know the answers to

Mike vs Milo

subodai vs kobe

Monkey crossbowman vs monkey explorer

sarah vs barnabus

scratch vs ratbeard

and finally

gortez vs troggy chief

you decide! I know the answers but do you?
its up to chance :P :P :P but this how it suppose to go -

mike smear Milo

Kobe eat up subodai right well

i dunno about the rags

Barnabas simply run for dear life when he come to Sarah :P

rat beard and scratch, i believe scratch would win because him epics work on rat beard, rat beard own don't work on him

and gortez and chief, gortez eat him

Petty Officer
Sep 02, 2011
67
Speed Switch on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
its up to chance :P :P :P but this how it suppose to go -

mike smear Milo

Kobe eat up subodai right well

i dunno about the rags

Barnabas simply run for dear life when he come to Sarah :P

rat beard and scratch, i believe scratch would win because him epics work on rat beard, rat beard own don't work on him

and gortez and chief, gortez eat him
Almost all correct. The one you skipped i counted wrong but subodai almost wins against kobe.

Here are some more i researched

Lucky jack vs milo

Kobe vs kan po

kan po vs wing chung

monkey king vs gortez

crazy monkey crossbow vs regular monkey crossbow

Romba vs nanu nanu

Sky snake vs scorpion

Old scratch vs valencia crab

vavadila bros

ensign vs crab harpoon

iago vs capello ( i think its spelled like that)

And finally tonka vs black storm raider.

The answers may surprise you!

Captain
May 02, 2009
525
unicornman987 on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
here are a few i know the answers to

Mike vs Milo

subodai vs kobe

Monkey crossbowman vs monkey explorer

sarah vs barnabus

scratch vs ratbeard

and finally

gortez vs troggy chief

you decide! I know the answers but do you?
Mike vs. Milo=Milo, Mike doesn't have enough accuracy nor dodge to beat Milo

Subodai vs. Kobe=Kobe, Subodai doesn't stand a chance, even with all that armor

Monquistador Crossbowman vs. Monquistador Explorer=Monquistador Explorer, simple as that

Sarah vs. Barnabus=As much as it pains me to say this, but Sarah beats Barnabus

Scratch vs. Ratbeard=Scratch, Ratbeard can't handle his mojo

Gorondo vs. Eep Ork Ooo Ah-Ah= Gorondo, he'll go bananas on that troggy

Community Leader
Undead Mike's only reason for living - er, existing is his loyalty to our family. Milo's only interested in his own moneymaking schemes.

Kobe & Subodai - pretty evenly matched, but Kan Po could take 'em both

Monkeys - My gold's on the Holy Monquisitor, he takes down guys four times his size then prays for them

Barnabus moves too slow to catch Sarah, as long as she keeps moving she should wear him down

I'll take Scratch over Ratbeard, since he can summon up some skeletal help

And like Barnabus, Gortez moves way too slow - the Troggy Chief's hopping circles 'round him & throwing mojo at him without getting in reach

Chatroom Moderator - Pieces of Eight Radio
Bosun
Oct 15, 2012
362
Gunner's Mate
Nov 01, 2012
216
unicornman987 on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
here are a few i know the answers to

Mike vs Milo

subodai vs kobe

Monkey crossbowman vs monkey explorer

sarah vs barnabus

scratch vs ratbeard

and finally

gortez vs troggy chief

you decide! I know the answers but do you?
Milo would definitley take down an undead guy any day

Subodai may not have as much damage but is a better blocker and defender which is enough to beat kobe

Monkey crossbowman who has a better chance of not missing with a bunch of arrows vs. a monkey with a spear do i even have to say

Sarah would turn barnabus into a million pieces of shredds

A tough one but scratch summons things from the dead and has witchdoctor powers so old scratch

Gortez would throw the troggy 7 million miles a way no chance gortez beats everyone
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Mericless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50

Petty Officer
Sep 02, 2011
67
These are all great guesses but the answers are

Mike
Kobe
Explorer
Tie!!!!!! This answer was a huge surprise!!!! Sarah had 12 health left but we decided to call it a draw but actually it was a win

Scratch

And this one many many people got wrong Troggy chief ill explain why. First of all gornandos epic talents don't effect the troggy chief because he is a witch!! However the troggies DOES affect gornando. Troggy also has poison and range! He can poison run let gornando catch up and then he gets hit by readied spell!!! This was a tough one but cheers for those who got it right!!!!
I also have a few more

Nurse Quinn vs nayda
Rooster cogburn vs thunder hoof
Black storm archer vs black storm raider
Chuck Norris vs Jackie chan?? Jk about that one
Crab thug vs crab harpoon
And finally the hardest one yet

Wing Chung vs........... Mormo this was a VERY interesting match

Ensign
Apr 21, 2009
29
unicornman987 on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
Almost all correct. The one you skipped i counted wrong but subodai almost wins against kobe.

Here are some more i researched

Lucky jack vs milo

Kobe vs kan po

kan po vs wing chung

monkey king vs gortez

crazy monkey crossbow vs regular monkey crossbow

Romba vs nanu nanu

Sky snake vs scorpion

Old scratch vs valencia crab

vavadila bros

ensign vs crab harpoon

iago vs capello ( i think its spelled like that)

And finally tonka vs black storm raider.

The answers may surprise you!
Lucky Jack vs. Milo - I don't have much experience with Milo but if he is as dodgy as people say he is I'll go with him because I know without buffs Jack's performance is based entirely off of luck, pun intended.

Kobe vs. Kan Po - Even match, but maybe Kobe, I would expect a lot of back in forth ripostes during the battle.

Kan Po vs. Wing Chun - Kan Po, even with the accuracy buff Wing Chun would never touch him.

Monkey King vs. Gortez - Monkey King versus the Golden Monkey King? Nice. I would guess Monkey King, he probably wouldn't hit a lot, but I doubt Gortez would even touch him without using a special.

Crazed Monquistador vs. Monquistador Crossbowman - Crossbowman just because he gets an upgrade/extra epic.

Romba vs. Nanu Nanu - Nanu Nanu, I can't stand Romba in battle.

Sky Snake vs. Scorpius - depends on their epics, if Sorpius has riposte then the Sky Snake's first strike could become quite the hinderance.

Old Scratch vs. Crab Hermit - Old Scratch because of the possible mojo echo chains.

Valvida bros. - Probably the skeletal one because he can siphon health.

Ensign vs. Louis - Really good match, I would guess Louis though because of his range, overwatch, and possible multiple quick draws.

Iago vs. Ridolfo - I know for a fact Iago has better base stats then Ridolfo (I find amusement in having two unicorns on the field at once)

Tonka vs. Black Storm Raider - I'm going to guess Tonka, not really fond of either to be honest.

Anne level 50
Bridget level 50
Mary level 50

Gunner's Mate
Nov 01, 2012
216
Captain McGeefus on Apr 14, 2013 wrote:
Lucky Jack vs. Milo - I don't have much experience with Milo but if he is as dodgy as people say he is I'll go with him because I know without buffs Jack's performance is based entirely off of luck, pun intended.

Kobe vs. Kan Po - Even match, but maybe Kobe, I would expect a lot of back in forth ripostes during the battle.

Kan Po vs. Wing Chun - Kan Po, even with the accuracy buff Wing Chun would never touch him.

Monkey King vs. Gortez - Monkey King versus the Golden Monkey King? Nice. I would guess Monkey King, he probably wouldn't hit a lot, but I doubt Gortez would even touch him without using a special.

Crazed Monquistador vs. Monquistador Crossbowman - Crossbowman just because he gets an upgrade/extra epic.

Romba vs. Nanu Nanu - Nanu Nanu, I can't stand Romba in battle.

Sky Snake vs. Scorpius - depends on their epics, if Sorpius has riposte then the Sky Snake's first strike could become quite the hinderance.

Old Scratch vs. Crab Hermit - Old Scratch because of the possible mojo echo chains.

Valvida bros. - Probably the skeletal one because he can siphon health.

Ensign vs. Louis - Really good match, I would guess Louis though because of his range, overwatch, and possible multiple quick draws.

Iago vs. Ridolfo - I know for a fact Iago has better base stats then Ridolfo (I find amusement in having two unicorns on the field at once)

Tonka vs. Black Storm Raider - I'm going to guess Tonka, not really fond of either to be honest.

Anne level 50
Bridget level 50
Mary level 50
All your answers are correct except one the second to last with ridolfo and iago. Even though i LOVE iago the person far better than him is ridolfo. why? because he gets THREE promotions iago only gets two and the three promotions allow him to have 4 EPIC powers the one he starts off with riposte and then another three epics with these choices bladestorm, relentless, first strike, repel boarders, and critical strike which you can only get once but the other epics you can get twice with each promotion

If you agree feel free to say so
Find me in the game
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Merciless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50

Petty Officer
Sep 02, 2011
67
Captain McGeefus on Apr 14, 2013 wrote:
Lucky Jack vs. Milo - I don't have much experience with Milo but if he is as dodgy as people say he is I'll go with him because I know without buffs Jack's performance is based entirely off of luck, pun intended.

Kobe vs. Kan Po - Even match, but maybe Kobe, I would expect a lot of back in forth ripostes during the battle.

Kan Po vs. Wing Chun - Kan Po, even with the accuracy buff Wing Chun would never touch him.

Monkey King vs. Gortez - Monkey King versus the Golden Monkey King? Nice. I would guess Monkey King, he probably wouldn't hit a lot, but I doubt Gortez would even touch him without using a special.

Crazed Monquistador vs. Monquistador Crossbowman - Crossbowman just because he gets an upgrade/extra epic.

Romba vs. Nanu Nanu - Nanu Nanu, I can't stand Romba in battle.

Sky Snake vs. Scorpius - depends on their epics, if Sorpius has riposte then the Sky Snake's first strike could become quite the hinderance.

Old Scratch vs. Crab Hermit - Old Scratch because of the possible mojo echo chains.

Valvida bros. - Probably the skeletal one because he can siphon health.

Ensign vs. Louis - Really good match, I would guess Louis though because of his range, overwatch, and possible multiple quick draws.

Iago vs. Ridolfo - I know for a fact Iago has better base stats then Ridolfo (I find amusement in having two unicorns on the field at once)

Tonka vs. Black Storm Raider - I'm going to guess Tonka, not really fond of either to be honest.

Anne level 50
Bridget level 50
Mary level 50
It is
Jack
Kan po
Surprise! I was wing!
Monkey king
Non crazed
Nanu nanu
Scorpion
Crab hermit
Skeleton
Ensign
Iago
Tonka

Ensign
Sep 30, 2012
25
unicornman987 on Apr 13, 2013 wrote:
These are all great guesses but the answers are

Mike
Kobe
Explorer
Tie!!!!!! This answer was a huge surprise!!!! Sarah had 12 health left but we decided to call it a draw but actually it was a win

Scratch

And this one many many people got wrong Troggy chief ill explain why. First of all gornandos epic talents don't effect the troggy chief because he is a witch!! However the troggies DOES affect gornando. Troggy also has poison and range! He can poison run let gornando catch up and then he gets hit by readied spell!!! This was a tough one but cheers for those who got it right!!!!
I also have a few more

Nurse Quinn vs nayda
Rooster cogburn vs thunder hoof
Black storm archer vs black storm raider
Chuck Norris vs Jackie chan?? Jk about that one
Crab thug vs crab harpoon
And finally the hardest one yet

Wing Chung vs........... Mormo this was a VERY interesting match
Nayda wins, anyone beats Nurse Quinn.

Rooster, he can use overwatch and run in circles around Thunder.(I have both)

Black Storm Raider, the archer has very little health and not a very far walk range.

Crab Harpooner, hands down. Crab thug is easy to dodge, but is very good when at his last promo.

I'm going with Mormo, as you said HIS epics effect Wing Chun, but Wing's don't effect Mormo.

Lieutenant
Jan 18, 2011
133
Don't know most but no offence: some are not worth the match ups you would try in p101(the matchups the person who started it). mostly because ratbeard and scratch want nothing with the other and a few others are odd too. here's a good suggestion:

Ratbeard vs Bonnie anne (they make sense since she really don't like ratbeard)

All starter monk companions vs each other (battle of the kung foo masters! i wish wing chun would win)

scropion queen vs neeka the nasty parrot of monquista

Spider queen and kings vs that old hermet who show up twice trying to win the treasure(hint captain gunn's gold and burey's gold). the crab hermet have the power to command his army of crawlies and the giant spiders in that bronco dungeon control other small spiders

Moo manchu vs ........... Deacon or Kane (duh duh dahhhhhhhhhhhhh!)

personally I really think that one would have been epic.

Lieutenant
Jan 18, 2011
133
Ethan the baron on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
Milo would definitley take down an undead guy any day

Subodai may not have as much damage but is a better blocker and defender which is enough to beat kobe

Monkey crossbowman who has a better chance of not missing with a bunch of arrows vs. a monkey with a spear do i even have to say

Sarah would turn barnabus into a million pieces of shredds

A tough one but scratch summons things from the dead and has witchdoctor powers so old scratch

Gortez would throw the troggy 7 million miles a way no chance gortez beats everyone
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Mericless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50
But us. your forgetting we could beat up gortez sometimes but if you compair the weaker/ non highly smart ones you can say he beats every monquistan in a fist fight and he would smash the chef, capture and roast the flying fish(barnabus is a flying fish right?) and maybe everyone in a banana pie eating contest ....

as for the others:

Subodai strong and well protected and kobe a monk, your dealing with the match of bronze vs brains so it varies ...

Monquistains are pretty much insane(at most) and have little trust on certain people(mostly pirates and humans which they call us hairless creatures due to our fair skin). so if i hear one person say they go bananas, let gortez smash them

Sarah could turn barnabus into a royal meal fit for a king er .... queen in this case

Sorry to say this but Old Scratch overall in the game is weak on physical and strong on magic .... If Ratbeard was as smart(and kind of a cheater) as he is he would steal scratch's wand leaving him the upper hand.

Black rashida level50

Lieutenant
Jan 18, 2011
133
Ethan the baron on Apr 14, 2013 wrote:
All your answers are correct except one the second to last with ridolfo and iago. Even though i LOVE iago the person far better than him is ridolfo. why? because he gets THREE promotions iago only gets two and the three promotions allow him to have 4 EPIC powers the one he starts off with riposte and then another three epics with these choices bladestorm, relentless, first strike, repel boarders, and critical strike which you can only get once but the other epics you can get twice with each promotion

If you agree feel free to say so
Find me in the game
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Merciless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50
correction: I have ridolfo and he gets Four promotions
(final one on level 50)

black Rashida level50

Petty Officer
Jan 18, 2013
58
unicornman987 on Apr 12, 2013 wrote:
here are a few i know the answers to

Mike vs Milo

subodai vs kobe

Monkey crossbowman vs monkey explorer

sarah vs barnabus

scratch vs ratbeard

and finally

gortez vs troggy chief

you decide! I know the answers but do you?
Milo all the way!
I think kobe
Monkey crossbow
sarah steele makes barnabus wet his armor
ratbeard at first, but when they're lvled up, scratch
never had either, but i would think gortez

Name: Arthur Lanyard

Gunner's Mate
Nov 01, 2012
216
winter goddess on Apr 15, 2013 wrote:
correction: I have ridolfo and he gets Four promotions
(final one on level 50)

black Rashida level50
No he only gets three promos and i know because i bought him three days ago and other players have also said he only gets three promos so i would double check just to make sure
Fino me in the game
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Merciless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50

Community Leader
Technically speaking there is no wrong answers here.
The OP is apparently unknowingly asking for opinions here, not facts, because "Who is better" is a matter of personal preference and style.

How a companion is trained could make a big difference as well (which is also based on personal preference and style).

I like to read these threads though as I often find responses rather humorous.
Its fun to see others perspectives.

Dr Zeppers (aka Silent Sam Stern)
Piratey parodies I like to make.
I be a crazy pirate for goodness sake!
Artist & Admin of Skull Island TV
Lieutenant
Jan 18, 2011
133
Ethan the baron on Apr 17, 2013 wrote:
No he only gets three promos and i know because i bought him three days ago and other players have also said he only gets three promos so i would double check just to make sure
Fino me in the game
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Merciless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50
My bad, i lost track cause its pretty hard.
By the way how am i gonna find you?

Gunner's Mate
Nov 01, 2012
216
winter goddess on Apr 18, 2013 wrote:
My bad, i lost track cause its pretty hard.
By the way how am i gonna find you?
Nobody has actually ever asked me this question but im always on realm avery and if you wanna know where i am just ask I will answer any question anyone gives me
Slick Cody Jones privateer lvl 50
Merciless Ethan Jenkins swashbuckler lvl 50