This is not a quest companion, but I think the cutthroat from the bundle would do it, being the thug type.

anecorbie on Jan 22, 2015 wrote:

This post was inspired by Durante, in which he asked "What would happen if the possibility of mutiny was added to the game?"
So I ask you, fellow pirates; which of your crew members would be most likely to start a mutiny and why.

I nominate Ratbeard and Tricky Vinnie in the role of chief conspirators in a mutiny because - 1. Has Ratbeard truly reformed? He's a pirate type, treachery is part of being a pirate.
2. Tricky Vinnie would want a bigger slice of the action ( and gold ).
Would Fan join in? She's a 'rather famous thief'. An offer of extra gold might sway her loyalty.

Here are my nominations:

1: Monkey King: When he figures out that the Crown of Command can be taken off.......he'll probably betray us. Or, he may stick with us, as he seems keen for an adventure.

2: Wing Chun: He keeps saying that he could do EVERYTHING that I can't do. Maybe that false thought will start a rebellion, and then I will need to cook his goose!

3: Prince Yulefest: If you take a look at his moves, and how many people have said that he's the closest we'll ever get to an Armada companion......that gets you thinking. Is he just a wooden version of an Armada soldier, made to be a spy? These facts are troubling.

4: Ratbeard: For most of the same reasons as what anecorbie listed. However, you do realize he has put his old ways and his old ghosts to rest, right? He may be a nefarious rodent, but he does offer advice and plans on how to succeed at any given mission.

5: Yakooza companion: Your pirate is RICH. Yakooza steal from the rich to give to the poor, so what's to stop a MASSIVE brute like him from taking your gold reserves?

COMPANIONS THAT WON'T BETRAY YOU:

1: Bonnie Anne: She's a girl of her word. She's as loyal as Lucky Jack Russell! She's probably the equivalent of the player pirate's foster mother while you are on your adventure!

2: ANY Samoorai: They are loyal and honorable, and if you take a look in real life, Samurai followed a code of honor, sacrifice, and obedience. The Samoorai would sooner put down a mutiny than start one!

3: Ninja Pig: He is an assassin, but he is just like the Samoorai. Loyal and obedient to his master, his missions may risk his life, but that thought never gets in the way, as he is devoted to his master/captain.

4: Rooster Cogburn: He is out to enforce the law, and since that is what your pirate is doing, he will stay with you. If a mutiny occurs, expect him to have all the masterminds of it in handcuffs within the afternoon.

5: Lucky Jack Russell: He knows you're the closest thing he has to his old captains, your parents. He couldn't bear it if you were to be killed in a munity, and he would sooner give his life for you stopping a rebellion than start a rebellion.

An excellent idea for a thread. I would have to go with Monkey King... because he's bored.

Ratbeard, I don't think so. For one thing, every time he suggests we blow something up, we do it. So, him we are keeping entertained.

-Indigo

warriorscreed on Jan 22, 2015 wrote:

Here are my nominations:

1: Monkey King: When he figures out that the Crown of Command can be taken off.......he'll probably betray us. Or, he may stick with us, as he seems keen for an adventure.

2: Wing Chun: He keeps saying that he could do EVERYTHING that I can't do. Maybe that false thought will start a rebellion, and then I will need to cook his goose!

3: Prince Yulefest: If you take a look at his moves, and how many people have said that he's the closest we'll ever get to an Armada companion......that gets you thinking. Is he just a wooden version of an Armada soldier, made to be a spy? These facts are troubling.

4: Ratbeard: For most of the same reasons as what anecorbie listed. However, you do realize he has put his old ways and his old ghosts to rest, right? He may be a nefarious rodent, but he does offer advice and plans on how to succeed at any given mission.

5: Yakooza companion: Your pirate is RICH. Yakooza steal from the rich to give to the poor, so what's to stop a MASSIVE brute like him from taking your gold reserves?

COMPANIONS THAT WON'T BETRAY YOU:

1: Bonnie Anne: She's a girl of her word. She's as loyal as Lucky Jack Russell! She's probably the equivalent of the player pirate's foster mother while you are on your adventure!

2: ANY Samoorai: They are loyal and honorable, and if you take a look in real life, Samurai followed a code of honor, sacrifice, and obedience. The Samoorai would sooner put down a mutiny than start one!

3: Ninja Pig: He is an assassin, but he is just like the Samoorai. Loyal and obedient to his master, his missions may risk his life, but that thought never gets in the way, as he is devoted to his master/captain.

4: Rooster Cogburn: He is out to enforce the law, and since that is what your pirate is doing, he will stay with you. If a mutiny occurs, expect him to have all the masterminds of it in handcuffs within the afternoon.

5: Lucky Jack Russell: He knows you're the closest thing he has to his old captains, your parents. He couldn't bear it if you were to be killed in a munity, and he would sooner give his life for you stopping a rebellion than start a rebellion.

A side note regarding the Yakooza:

The Yakooza are based off of the Japanese crime syndicate the Yakuza (if you didn't already know that). They are not necessarily Robin Hoods, but they try to make sure that those under their protection are safe and content. In return, the gangsters will get some sort of tribute from the territory that they are protecting. It's a mutual partnership.

warriorscreed on Jan 22, 2015 wrote:

Here are my nominations:

1: Monkey King: When he figures out that the Crown of Command can be taken off.......he'll probably betray us. Or, he may stick with us, as he seems keen for an adventure.

2: Wing Chun: He keeps saying that he could do EVERYTHING that I can't do. Maybe that false thought will start a rebellion, and then I will need to cook his goose!

3: Prince Yulefest: If you take a look at his moves, and how many people have said that he's the closest we'll ever get to an Armada companion......that gets you thinking. Is he just a wooden version of an Armada soldier, made to be a spy? These facts are troubling.

4: Ratbeard: For most of the same reasons as what anecorbie listed. However, you do realize he has put his old ways and his old ghosts to rest, right? He may be a nefarious rodent, but he does offer advice and plans on how to succeed at any given mission.

5: Yakooza companion: Your pirate is RICH. Yakooza steal from the rich to give to the poor, so what's to stop a MASSIVE brute like him from taking your gold reserves?

COMPANIONS THAT WON'T BETRAY YOU:

1: Bonnie Anne: She's a girl of her word. She's as loyal as Lucky Jack Russell! She's probably the equivalent of the player pirate's foster mother while you are on your adventure!

2: ANY Samoorai: They are loyal and honorable, and if you take a look in real life, Samurai followed a code of honor, sacrifice, and obedience. The Samoorai would sooner put down a mutiny than start one!

3: Ninja Pig: He is an assassin, but he is just like the Samoorai. Loyal and obedient to his master, his missions may risk his life, but that thought never gets in the way, as he is devoted to his master/captain.

4: Rooster Cogburn: He is out to enforce the law, and since that is what your pirate is doing, he will stay with you. If a mutiny occurs, expect him to have all the masterminds of it in handcuffs within the afternoon.

5: Lucky Jack Russell: He knows you're the closest thing he has to his old captains, your parents. He couldn't bear it if you were to be killed in a munity, and he would sooner give his life for you stopping a rebellion than start a rebellion.

Aye I agree with ye about Jack

Probably Monkey King, who knows where he'll go if we take that crown inside his helmet off.

Quentin Davenport, lvl 65

Marcus Davenport, lvl 22