S Tier - Buccaneers, insane chains and for some reason is also tanky.
A Tier - Privateer and Musketeer. Can deal with Buccaneers/outlast them and abuse Angry Orchard to help deal with them
B Tier - Swashbuckler, are ok but struggle more or less now since Buccaneers can out grind them and with first strike strategies disable their entire main game plan. Same for Privateers and Musketeers can just knockback bombs and camp a corner to survive initial start.
C Tier - Witchdoctors. Everything a Witch can do, Privateer can do better. Weakest class against buccaneers. Can beat Privateers hard and Swashbuckler is 50/50 but struggle to deal with angry orchard musketeers with Nausica+Goro core.
So uh, you're quite hot on witchdoctor buddy. You do realize that witch hunter makes all witch doctor strats that aren't hardcore summon spam non-viable right? The order of the rest looks pretty good, but I have a few problems with putting exactly one class in each tier.
Here's what I'd say the tier list looks like
S: Privy with full cheese set (trees, banner, scratch, boon/nausica, cottas)
A+: Privy without cheese
B: Musketeer, Swashbuckler
Writer, Editor, Administrator, and Pirate PvP guy at FinalBastion
Check us out for all things Pirate101 and Wizard101 PvE/PvP