On the Battleboard as I understand it, the Blue Dot is supposed to indicate that orders still need to be given and a Green Check Mark is supposed to indicate an order has been given along with the effect of the order. But, my Pirate's icon shows a Blue Dot and a Green Check Mark. The order that I have given him is normally shown by either an indicator that I am doing something or a movement line if I am moving and/or attacking or a dotted line showing I am casting a spell and exactly where I am casting the spell. Any of the mentioned indicators have been replaced by the Blue Dot. When I click the Done button, the order that I have given him is carried out like normal.
I don't think the Blue Dot is supposed be on the Battleboard at the end of giving commands.